The original decision of the Tribunal rejected PPL’s proposed tariff where larger establishments paid more than smaller ones in favour of a “one size fits all” rate of just over £100 per annum.  As a result bars with a thousand drinkers will pay exactly the same for their PPL Licence as small pubs with only a handful of regulars.  PPL decided to appeal the decision to the High Court.

In a judgement handed down today Mr Justice Arnold dismissed the collecting society’s appeal finding that the Tribunal had not erred in law.  PPL have expressed their disappointment at the decision which they believe leave PPL with tariffs that substantially undervalue the rights of its members.

Commenting on the decision BASCA CEO Patrick Rackow said “It is depressing that, at a time when we are trying to maintain the economic value of music in the public’s perception, the Copyright Tribunal should reach a decision that not only drives that value down but appears to fly in the face of common sense.  It is even more depressing when such decisions are confirmed on appeal.”